Report of the
PRCUA Growth and Development Committee
Ad Hoc
Committee:
Dir.
William Nowakowski, Chairman
Pres. Wallace M. Ozog, Executive Committee Representative*
Dir. Barbara Toboy*
Dir. Edward Kaplaniak
Dir. Joan Sylak
Dir. Lillian Stempinski
Dir. Elizabeth Grabowski
(* not present at the meeting)
INTRODUCTION
This document is an outline to discuss various
considerations for the growth, development and evolution of the P.R.C.U.A.
The goal of this outline is to establish talking points about areas of
concern along with specific items that can be considered to enhance the
growth and membership of the P.R.C.U.A. It addresses the organizational,
fraternal and financial activities of the organization.
Items presented herein take into account the
National Fraternal Congress, Fraternal Vision Subcommittee's Final Report,
which evaluated the status of all fraternal organizations. The NFCA report
can be used as a guide for considering the future activities of this
organization as part of the fraternal community.
It is expected that proposals, that this
committee and the board deem worthy of consideration, would be followed up
with additional research and fact-finding. This would include having
presentations made to the board and/or to the committee laying out the
specific details of items considered, including the cost of undertakings,
the potential benefits to be garnered along with an analysis of any
potential risk and economic impact that it would have on the organization.
I. How to Attract New Members & Retain
Existing Members.
A. Marketing and Sales
Essential for future growth and development of
this organization will be the necessity of identifying and reaching out to
persons of Polish or Slavic descent, who would meet the requirements for
membership within the organization. Many problem areas include the
difficulty in recruiting deputies and supervisors in the states in which
P.R.C.U.A. is licensed to sell products and to effectively market our
products. These problems could be
addressed by:
1) Retaining a highly qualified national sales
director with duties to include the recruitment of deputies in each
district; training new and existing deputies; evaluating the existing
commission structure and developing a commission structure that will attract
new deputies and conform to the new actuarial tables recently approved for
use by the Union.
2) Develop and implement an effective
marketing plan for the Union's products and benefits. This can be
accomplished by requesting bids or proposals from outside agencies or hiring
a properly educated and experienced marketing professional.
B. Young Members
Retention of younger members is critical to
our future. It is necessary to have our younger members more fully
participate in the organization. It is then incumbent to create a structure
that will instill enthusiasm among the youth. In this respect, the Committee
believes that establishing a "Youth Czar" will set the foundation for
increased participation. It is envisioned that the Youth Czar try to develop
networks among our younger members, have a designated by-line in the
official organ, develop and implement
programs that create greater activity among this peer group, and report to
the board of directors.
In conjunction with the Youth Czar, serious
consideration should be given to implementing the recommendations of the
Youth Committee Report to the last quadrennial convention.
C. Identifying & Reaching New Potential
Members
In order for the organization to grow and
succeed, it will be necessary to identify persons who would be interested in
joining the organization. Ideally, these are persons between ages 24 to 48
who are in careers and have growing families. Before P.R.C.U.A. can market
or sell to a new group of individuals, it must know the following:
-
Why
would a person join this organization or a fraternal organization?
-
What
activities or goals of the organization would be important to a person
that would cause them to join?
-
What
specific products or services, or combination thereof, would be
significant to a person that would cause them to become a member of the
organization?
It
becomes apparent that the P.R.C.U.A. needs to specifically isolate people
who identify themselves as being of Polish or Slavic heritage as opposed to
those who may simply have Polish or Slavic surnames. If and when such
persons can be identified as potential members, the goal will be to market
P.R.C.U.A. benefits and products in a method that reinforces the reasons
that one would consider membership.
How do we get the answers to the above?
The only way to obtain information that would
be reliable is to undertake a scientific survey that would provide answers
from participants who identify themselves as Polish or Slavic persons within
the age group desired. Such a survey would have to be done on a large scale,
at least in the majority of the states in which the P.R.C.U.A. conducts
business, in order to account for geographic differences in attitudes. A
survey would be expensive, but could provide the P.R.C.U.A. with tools to
structure the organization, its products and services in a manner to
significantly increase membership.
Options for obtaining this information would
include:
-
Ask
other fraternals if they have conducted such studies and ask if they
would be willing to provide or share their survey results with us.
-
Conduct our own scientific survey.
-
The
P.R.C.U.A. could jointly work with other fraternals to share in the cost
of conducting such a survey that would result in mutually beneficial
information.
-
Seek
grants to underwrite the cost of such a survey. Alternatively, an
informal survey could be undertaken through the Narod Polski and the
Union's website, which at least could provide an understanding of what
current members by age and location desire as to fraternal activities,
and financial services which may cause greater participation in the
organization.
If the
committee believes that this is a recommendation that should be forwarded to
the board of directors, it is suggested that the executive committee
undertake to interview various scientific surveying companies to determine
the scope of the survey that would be needed and the associated cost.
Various bid proposals from several survey companies could be presented to
the board detailing the scope and the expense of such a survey. The board
would then determine the feasibility and advisability of pursuing a survey.
II. Services That Can Be Introduced In The
Near Term To Assist With Member Retention And Enhance Growth Of New Members
The financial services industry, as a whole,
has been moving toward one-stop shopping. Organizations, such as Thrivent as
well as the United Services Automobile Association (USAA), have created
one-stop shopping providing their members with complete financial services.
Other fraternal organizations have also moved towards expanding the
services, which they offer their members. A number of fraternals have
undertaken to establish federal credit unions or federal savings banks.
A. Savings Bank or Federal Credit Union
The establishment of a federal savings bank or
credit union can greatly enhance the ability of this organization to provide
common everyday financial services for its members and employees. The merger
of the Alliance of Poles in Cleveland with the P.R.C.U.A. has yielded an
opportunity for strong linkage to a credit union. The Alliance of Poles
Federal Credit Union (FCU) recently had its field of membership expanded to
include all P.R.C.U.A. members. The establishment of a close working
relationship with the FCU can create the opportunity for the P.R.C.U.A. to
sell its products through the FCU, in mutually beneficial association,
creating a synergy of financial services for the benefit of our members.
The FCU has a very low asset base and in order
to provide meaningful services it will need to increase its deposits and
loans significantly in order to be an effective partner with the P.R.C.U.A.
Numerous products and benefits could be
offered to P.R.C.U.A. members. These include establishing an integrated
service where our members could obtain online information about all of the
products and services that they may be utilizing in our organization, and
acting as a method to advertise the activities of the P.R.C.U.A. to credit
union members.
The following services could be provided to
members either initially or progressively over time:
-
Savings accounts;
-
Interest bearing checking accounts;
-
Mortgages;
-
Auto
loans;
-
Money
market accounts;
-
Safety deposit boxes;
-
Certificates of deposit;
-
Affiliated credits cards;
-
Debit
Cards;
-
Online banking/financial services;
-
Mutual Fund Sales;
-
Student Loans;
-
Second Mortgage Loans;
-
Home-Equity Loans;
-
Vacation Home Loan;
-
Condominium Residence Loans;
-
Mutual Fund Sales;
-
CD or
High Interest Savings Accounts.
B. Insurance Based
Products
Greater diversity of insurance products
will retain membership in the P.R.C.U.A. and entice new members to join. The
P.R.C.U.A. must look to expand the scope of the insurance products that it
now offers, especially in products that are experiencing growth nationally.
1) Prepaid Monument or Tombstone
Coverage
The Union should explore the issuance of
insurance specifically geared to paying for a memorial, as permitted by
Section 297.1 of the Illinois Insurance Code.
The product could help offset funeral
related expenses and could name the monument provider as a direct
beneficiary. The member is thus assured that his or her final resting place
will have the memorial marker they desire. Further research will be needed
to determine if this type of policy can meet the Medicaid exception relating
to final funeral arrangements. If it does, it could provide a member with
peace of mind knowing that they
will have a memorial even if they pass while on Medicaid.
2) Charitable Giving or Donation
Policies
Another area of growth and interest,
especially in light of the aging population, are policies that would be
specifically geared toward the benefit of a certain charitable or cultural
organizations. These products could either be marketed through the
organization, which will be the beneficiary, and/or through the P.R.C.U.A.
itself. The development of this type of policy should be fairly easy to
accomplish using the existing structure for basic life insurance products
that the P.R.C.U.A. presently offers.
These policies could be aimed at such
groups as Orchard Lake Schools, the Polish Museum of America, and other
charitable foundations or religious organizations. The development of these
products would then indoctrinate the beneficiary organizations as active
producers of new membership for the organization through their solicitations
for their benefit.
Further study of these types of products
should be undertaken including identifying organizations would be interested
in working with the P.R.C.U.A. to establish a mutually beneficial
relationship.
3) Return of Premium Term Life
Insurance
A number of insurers have begun using
return of premium term life policies, when certain conditions were met.
These types of policies may be attractive to younger people who do not wish
to purchase whole life but are still looking for some return on their
insurance outlays. The Union should study the viability of
offering this coverage.
C. Non-Life-Insurance
Products
The committee should also consider the
possibility of the P.R.C.U.A. developing other types of insurance products
such as long-term care, drug benefit or disability insurance. These types of
products have also been increasing in growth due to the aging population of
the membership. The cost and feasibility of undertaking these types of
products needs to be studied in greater detail.
Information can be obtained from our
actuary and various other sources to determine the costs and the pricing
structure that could be established for these types of programs. It is
recommended that the executive officers undertake further study of these
non-life-insurance products and determine the feasibility of implementing
them.
Investigation into having other financial
services underwritten by a larger organization is also warranted. A
discussion should be had with Thrivent and other large fraternal benefit
societies to determine: if it is legally possible for them to act in such a
capacity, and the associated fees and expenses involved. Alternatively, the
possible formation of a National
Fraternal Holding Company could be studied in order to provide a centralized
source of products for all its members, with significant assets to leverage
better rates to its members.
D. Modernization and
Increased Computerization
In order to properly serve and retain
P.R.C.U.A. members, it will be necessary to improve and expand our
computerization. There has been ongoing progress in this area but there are
many items which still need to be addressed. The development of
comprehensive online computer services would be another tool to enhance the
ability of people to become members, as well as providing the ability for
people to access the organization on a regular basis. In this regard, the
comprehensive online program should consider adding the following options to
service members and attract new ones:
-
Availability for online quotes and
sales of policies over the Internet
-
Provide individuals with the ability
to review the status of their accounts including annuities, mortgages,
certificate values and status.
-
Estate planning information -
providing basic information about the various insuring products and how
they could be of value for planning their future and that of the
children and grandchildren.
-
Basic tax information about the
products that are offered by the P.R.C.U.A. including annuities; i.e.
tax penalties, when an annuity can be withdrawn, etc.
-
Creating society chat rooms to allow
for virtual meetings of societies and districts; and
-
Developing on the website a
password-protected list of names, e-mail addresses, addresses and phone
numbers for each society. This information could then be updated by the
home office each time a new member is added.
F. Other Growth Options
and Considerations
-
Continue mergers with smaller
fraternals by active solicitation;
-
Merger with a comparable or larger
fraternal;
-
Assisted takeover of a subsidiary
insurance company via a state insurance department.
This would assume control of an insurance company as an affiliated
subsidiary through an insurance commission of a state, which would
guarantee the payments under the policies and eliminate the assumption
of any debt of the company. Further investigation of this option is
recommended. The takeover of a subsidiary company could yield benefits
such as an increased sales force that could be used to market the
P.R.C.U.A.'s products.
G. Long Term
Considerations
For the organization to grow and prosper,
it must continue to expand its horizons to look for different services and
products. Study of larger, more capital-intensive alternative lines of
products should be undertaken as part of on ongoing review process. The
following would represent some possibilities for long-term investigation and
development.
This could be done by establishing joint
ventures and/or holding companies to allow for creation of larger capital
products founded on a multi-organizational platform such as a fraternal
holding company. This type of venture would be capable of developing and
implementing large capital-intensive products through which each
participating organization could offer services or products to the
individual members. Potential partners could include:
-
Larger Polish and Slavic fraternals;
-
Establishing a holding company with
in the framework of the National Fraternal Congress and/or forming joint
ventures with it to undertake funding of new products;
-
Seek parallel or joint venturing with
organizations such as a Catholic Church or other large cultural or
charitable institutions.
-
Establishing subsidiaries that would
be able to offer financial or insurance products the Union is currently
not able to offer itself.
III. Organizational and
Management Considerations
Presently the P.R.C.U.A. Task Force is
studying ways reorganize the structure of the Union and create a new and
modern constitution as was previously urged by this committee and adopted by
the last convention.
Pending the report of the Task Force,
there remain other options to better the organization including:
1) Adopt and employ an effective
team-oriented management system such as Six Sigma by having the executive
officers and managers undertake this training. This management style would
improve efficiency, productivity, profitability and employee morale;
2) Retain and utilize a professional
money manager/broker to enhance the performance of the Union’s portfolio
assets. This will also free the executive officers from the burden of trying
to act as financial professionals and free their time to focus on increasing
membership.
The money manger/broker would also be
able to provide detailed financial analysis, which heretofore has not been
available to the Board of Directors; and
3) Improve reporting to members,
especially annuity owners, by providing them with quarterly reports on their
accounts.
IV. Conclusion
The full Committee strongly urges the
Board of Directors to charge the executive officers to investigate and
report their findings, as to each of the categories discussed herein, no
later than at the final board meeting of the calendar year. It is further
suggested that each officer be tasked to address specific categories
identified above. The reports of the executive officers on each area should
then be published in the Narod Polski and on the P.R.C.U.A. website.
Respectfully Submitted,
William E. Nowakowski, Chairman